The rights of unmarried couples have been strengthened by the recent Supreme Court decision in favour of Siobhan McLaughlin, an unmarried mother from Northern Ireland.


Ms McLaughlin and her partner, John Adams, had been together for 23 years and had 4 children together.  However when he died from cancer in 2014, she was refused a widowed parent’s allowance for her bereaved children.  She will now receive an extra £117.00 per week as a result of her success at the Supreme Court. Widowed Parent’s Allowance was previously only available for married couples or civil partners however the Supreme Court found that this incompatible with Human Rights legislation. The judgement established that it should not matter whether or not parents are married, or in a civil partnership, and clarifies that the purpose of the Widowed Parent’s Allowance is to assist widows, with dependent children, regardless of their marital status.


Although this judgement relates specifically to the facts of Mrs McLaughlin’s case, the decision could have a greater impact on unmarried couple’s rights moving forward.



  • Thousands of families could now benefit from Widowed Parent’s Allowance.
  • Other benefits that favour married couples may be challenged relying on this precedent.
  • There will be increased pressure for legal reform relating to the rights of unmarried couples.
  • Unmarried couples could begin to receive similar protection to married couples.



Despite this positive movement towards equal rights there remains a disproportionate lack of protection for unmarried couples in family law.  This is a problem which can create severe financial hardship for families upon death or separation. To combat this lack of protection many unmarried couples rely on cohabitation agreements or ‘living together agreements’ for some form of protection.


If you are interested in discussing cohabitation agreements or if you would like to speak to us regarding any other family related legal matters then please do not hesitate to contact our dedicated family team at Nalders.

Truro | Farley House

Tel: 01872 241414, Fax: (01872) 242424

St Austell

Tel: 01726 879333, Fax: (01726) 67401
Tel: 01326 313441, Fax: (01326) 315971
Tel: 01637 871414, Fax: (01637) 879414

Truro | Lemon Street

Tel: 01872 241414, Fax: (01872) 271019
Tel: 01209 714278, Fax: (01209) 710437
Tel: 01326 574001, Fax: (01326) 564547
Tel: 01736 364014, Fax: (01736) 364054

Nalders Solicitors is a trading name of Nalders LLP and is a Limited Liability Partnership registered in England and Wales (LLP No. OC354499). We use the term partner to refer to a member of Nalders LLP. A list of the members may be inspected at our registered office: Farley House, Falmouth Road, Truro, Cornwall. TR1 2HX. Nalders LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority No. 538003. Resolution Accredited Specialist. We will not accept service by electronic mail. VAT Registration No. 131 8555 74